Insights · Document fraud

How do insurers detect forged sick leave certificates and repair receipts in claims?

In March 2026 Hong Kong police arrested 16 people on suspicion of forging documents such as sick leave certificates and car repair receipts to support or inflate traffic accident insurance claims. Supporting documents are usually the weakest point in a claim, and also the easiest to check.

In short

Usually by checking each document against its claimed source and against other claims. The quickest test is verification with the issuing clinic or workshop. Digital examination can then compare a document with genuine examples for layout, fonts, logos and numbering, and examine file metadata in PDFs and scans, such as the software used and creation dates, as far as it survives. Across a portfolio, patterns often stand out: the same template, device or wording appearing in claims that should be unrelated. None of this proves who made a document, and findings are stated as consistent or inconsistent with genuine examples; the courts decide what weight to give them.

What was reported

RTHK reported on 19 March 2026 that police had arrested 16 people over suspected “cash for crash” traffic accident insurance claims totalling HK$3.6 million. They were suspected of forging documents, including sick leave certificates and car repair receipts, and of exaggerating claims. Police said they had reviewed 430 suspicious claims referred by the insurance industry and the public, and that these arrests related to 11 claims.

No charges had been reported when the report was published. We do not identify anyone involved and draw no conclusions about them or any claim.

What digital document checks look at

  • Source verification. Confirming with the clinic, doctor or workshop that the document was issued, in that form and amount.
  • Comparison. Layout, fonts, logos, stamps and numbering against genuine documents from the same issuer and period.
  • File metadata. The software, device and dates recorded in PDFs and scans, where they have not been stripped.
  • Editing traces. Signs that text or figures were altered, such as mismatched fonts or compression.
  • Portfolio patterns. The same template, device, wording or errors appearing across unrelated claims.

D3 examines digital documents and files. Physical examination of paper, ink and handwriting is a separate discipline.

For insurers and claims handlers

Ask for original digital files, not just printouts or photographs, because originals keep more metadata. Verify a sample of supporting documents directly with issuers, within the authority given on the claim form, and look for repeated features across claims. Keep the files exactly as received, with a record of how they arrived and a hash of each file on receipt, so they can be examined later. Where fraud is suspected, take advice before contacting the claimant or their representatives.

See forged payslips and document forensics and computer forensics.

Sources

General commentary on public reports, not legal advice and not a finding about any organisation or person named in those reports. Facts are as reported at the time of writing.

Frequently asked questions

How do insurers detect forged sick leave certificates and repair receipts in claims?

By verifying documents with the issuing clinic or workshop, comparing them with genuine examples, examining file metadata in PDFs and scans, and looking for repeated templates or devices across unrelated claims.

Can metadata show a document was forged?

It can show inconsistencies, such as editing software or dates that do not fit the claimed origin, but metadata can be missing or altered. It is one strand of evidence, not proof on its own.

Why ask for original digital files?

Originals usually keep metadata and detail that printouts, photographs and re-scans lose.

Can forensic analysis show who forged a document?

Rarely on its own. It can show whether a document is consistent with genuine examples and sometimes link documents to a common source; who made it usually needs other evidence.

Does D3 examine handwriting and ink?

No. D3 examines digital documents and files. Physical examination of paper, ink and handwriting is a separate discipline.

Facing something like this?

The first discussion is confidential and free, and usually changes what you decide to do next. Call +852 5808 1071 or use the case review form.