Can data be recovered from a phone that was deliberately destroyed?
In May 2026 Hong Kong police raided a suspected phone-scam centre in Kwai Chung, arrested 13 people and seized more than 40 tablets and mobile phones. Police said some of those arrested tried to destroy their phones during the arrest; that is the police account and we draw no inference from it. Whatever the reason, damaging a phone does not always put its contents out of reach.
Sometimes, depending on what was damaged. A cracked screen, water damage or a broken charging port often leaves the memory and main processor intact, and a specialist can sometimes repair the phone, or move its key chips to a working board, and then examine it, usually still needing the passcode. On most modern phones, reading the memory chip on its own yields nothing readable, because the encryption keys are held in the processor. If the chips themselves are shattered or burned, recovery from the device is usually not possible. Even then, evidence often survives elsewhere: in cloud backups and synced accounts, on the other party’s phone, on computers, in SIM and phone card records, and with service providers, which usually release records only to the police or under a court order.
What was reported
RTHK reported on 8 May 2026 that police raided an industrial building in Kwai Chung the previous day and arrested 13 people over a suspected triad-run phone-scam centre. Police said callers posed as finance company staff chasing “arrears”, knowing victims’ names, addresses, identity card numbers and debt details, and that at least 20 cases involved losses of more than HK$1 million each. More than 40 tablets and mobile phones, phone cards, cash and computers were seized. Police said “The seized computers also showed personal data had been collected from more than 2,000 people”, and that some of those arrested had tried to destroy their phones during the arrest.
Those arrested had not been charged when the report was published. We do not identify them and draw no conclusions about them.
What can and cannot be recovered
- Surface damage. Broken screens, ports or buttons usually leave data intact; the phone can often be repaired enough to examine it.
- Water and impact. Prompt, careful handling by a specialist improves the chances; attempting to power the phone on may make things worse.
- Chip-level work. Where the board is damaged, specialists may be able to move the key chips to a working board. Reading the memory chip on its own usually yields nothing readable on modern phones, because the keys are held in the processor.
- Destroyed memory. If the storage chip is physically destroyed, recovery from the device itself is usually not possible.
- Elsewhere. Cloud accounts, other people’s phones, computers, SIM and phone card records and provider records often hold much of the same information.
How and when a device was damaged should be documented, because it can be relevant.
If you need to rely on a damaged phone
Do not keep trying to switch it on or charge it, and do not take it to a general repair shop, which may replace the parts that matter. If it is still on, tell the specialist straight away, because it may need to be kept off networks to prevent a remote wipe. Otherwise keep it as it is, note what happened to it, and have it examined by a forensic specialist who documents each step. Ask your lawyer early about preserving other sources, such as cloud accounts and, through consent, the police or a court order, the other party’s devices, because accounts can be deleted. Do not log in to anyone else’s accounts.
See forensic data recovery, mobile phone forensics and scam call centres and money mules.
Sources
General commentary on public reports, not legal advice and not a finding about any organisation or person named in those reports. Facts are as reported at the time of writing.
Frequently asked questions
Can data be recovered from a phone that was deliberately destroyed?
Sometimes. If the memory and processor survive, data can sometimes be recovered by repairing the phone or moving its chips to a working board, usually still needing the passcode. If the chips are destroyed, recovery from the device is usually not possible, but evidence often survives in cloud accounts, other devices and provider records.
Can data be recovered from a phone with a smashed screen?
Usually, though the passcode may still be needed. A broken screen rarely damages the storage, and the phone can often be repaired or connected in other ways for examination.
Can a water-damaged phone be examined?
Often, if it is handled quickly and correctly. Do not keep switching it on or charging it; keep it sealed and take it to a forensic specialist.
Does encryption stop recovery from a damaged phone?
It can. Modern phones encrypt data with keys tied to the hardware and passcode, so reading the memory chip on its own usually yields nothing readable.
Where else can phone evidence be found?
In cloud backups and synced accounts, on the other party’s phone, on computers, in SIM and phone card records and with service providers, which usually release records only to the police or under a court order, although you can request your own data.
Facing something like this?
The first discussion is confidential and free, and usually changes what you decide to do next. Call +852 5808 1071 or use the case review form.